MORE TH>N 1FORTY

Ben Israel on all things conversational

  • Home
    • Edit
    • Delete
    • Tags
    • Autopost

    Screw you, this is social media #mol #offgamers

    Yesterday, Ganesh Kumar Bangah, CEO of MOL (which acquired Friendster and recently signed a partnership with Facebook to become a payment provider for Facebook Credits), paid a visit to the OffGamers Facebook community page and:

    (1) made an unwelcomed remark that its gaming service was better than the competitor's

    Mol1

    (2) indicated that people who didn't agree that MOL's product was better, were... un-intelligent. To him, it should be plain to all, since his brand is BIGGER

    Mol2

    (3) after the page admin kindly offered to carry MOL's game credit products, said "no thank you, you are of no value to us"

    Mol3

     
     
    You can read the Twitter and Facebook reactions for yourselves. It has now spilled over to the Lowyat forum and  MOL's own Facebook page.
     
    But what baffled me the most were Ganesh's final words: "I understand that you may be upset that we are gate crashing, but this is social media". 
     
    "...but this is social media"??? What does that mean?
     
    I hope he isn't of the opinion that social media is the wild wild west, and no rules apply. That is a huge myth. The misconception that you can do and say what you want on social media without consequences is a major mistake. Social media is made up of people and communities, and the same rules of engaging with people offline apply online. What is rude offline, is rude online. What is considered shameless promoting offline, is still shameless promoting online. But unlike offline, where communication is one-to-one or one-to-a-few, what you do online is laid bare for all to see. Hence, adhering to the rules and etiquettes become even more important.
     
    In my opinion, the most important rule is respect the community. It isn't hard. e.g.:
    • Don't be rude
    • Don't say what you wouldn't want to see on your own page
    • Don't spam
    • Don't be a troll
    • Respect the on-going conversation
    • Understand the intent of the community before you participate
    • Add value, don't just push your own agenda
     
    Wait, don't we know all these things already?
     
     
     
    -- UPDATE --
     
    E27, the Singapore based web / mobile community, wrote to Ganesh for his side of the story. MOL's media liaison replied:
     
    "Thanks for your email. We have no plans to provide comments on the matter. Regards." 
     
    One of the commentators on the E27 blog said it best: "He is a CEO of a regional online company, but acted like a pasar-malam (night market) pirated VCD seller." #epicwin
    Tags » E27 Etiquette Facebook Ganesh Bangah Ganesh Kumar Bangah MOL MOL Faux Pas MOL OffGamers Malaysia Social Media OffGamers Online Community Rules of Social Media Social Media Social Media Etiquettes Social Media Faux Pas Social Media Gaffes Spam Troll
    • 20 July 2010
    • Views
    • Permalink
    • Tweet
    • 16 responses
    • Like
    • Comment
    almost 2 years ago Niki Cheong responded:
    One word: Sigh.

    Obviously "we" don't know all these things already. :|

    almost 2 years ago Thomas Chai responded:
    Thomas Chai
    I can't believe a CEO of such a "BIG" company having a kiddo mentality
    almost 2 years ago Hakim Albasrawy liked this post.
    almost 2 years ago Hakim Albasrawy responded:
    Hakim Albasrawy
    walauwei - whats going on here la. rude much?
    almost 2 years ago faz_kerk (Twitter) responded:
    Hat_yo__normal
    We know, but we need more work to make common sense become common practice
    almost 2 years ago (Facebook) responded:
    Perhaps he has the medial skills to discover these outlets, but not the social skills...
    almost 2 years ago (Facebook) responded:
    *media
    almost 2 years ago (Facebook) responded:
    I'm guessing that being a decent person would to any interaction - social media or not.

    Question is - if you're Ganesh's social media / PR advisor - what would be the next steps?

    almost 2 years ago Michael Feng responded:
    Michael Feng
    this is terrible!
    almost 2 years ago Chloe responded:
    This is not the first time he did this...
    almost 2 years ago Ben Israel responded:
    Ben Israel
    @khailee first thing to do is acknowledge mistake and apologise. Then start the painful journey to rebuilding relationship with the community

    @chloe got more details about past sins?

    almost 2 years ago Leremy responded:
    Understanding of Social Media FAIL :)
    almost 2 years ago Chloe responded:
    Saw the similar act by in a forum on the topic "Cherry Credits" quite some time ago... The moderator of that forum got the post removed after some time.
    almost 2 years ago Jason Gan responded:
    Jason Gan
    This is seriously a big mistake he did for MOL brand, and I believe apology is not enough, some serious education is needed for the ego part.
    almost 2 years ago Klippe responded:
    Mr. G said he has the bigger brand, yadda yadda & out of curiosity I checked mol.com and offgamers.com on Alexa and here's the surprise I found, Offgamers looked much bigger than MOL to me.

    They have about the same rank in Malaysia, Philippines but in other countries like USA, UK, China, Singapore it seemed to me Offgamers is ranked way higher than MOL, except in India.

    If you only look at Malaysia, both are ranked in the 400's but Malaysia makes up on 27% of Offgamers' total traffic while it's 61% of MOL's !!

    Overall world traffic rank, Offgamers is ranked 32,356 and MOL is ranked 65,337, more than double????

    Did Mr. G even get that part of the fact wrong and the only thing bigger he ever had was an oversized ego?

    References:
    http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/mol.com#
    http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/offgamers.com#

    P/S - Alexa experts out there, do correct me if I am wrong interpreting the data....

    almost 2 years ago Ali Goldie responded:
    So high on top, but forgetting the basics rule of being online. sigh..
  • Ben Israel's Space


  • About Ben Israel


  • Subscribe via RSS

    Archive

    2011 (14)
    August (1)
    July (2)
    June (1)
    May (4)
    March (2)
    February (2)
    January (2)
    2010 (56)
    December (2)
    October (6)
    September (5)
    August (5)
    July (6)
    June (7)
    May (4)
    April (7)
    March (2)
    February (6)
    January (6)
    2009 (36)
    December (3)
    November (12)
    October (7)
    September (9)
    August (5)
  • Follow Me

      TwitterFacebookBuzzFriendfeedFlickrDelicious

Theme created for Posterous by Obox